|
The Splendid Table's First Ever Blind Chocolate Candy Tasting
December 1, 2007
Listen to this feature (How to listen)
As a public service, we decided to taste-test for chocolates that would be worthy of gift-giving. We picked chocolatiers from across the country and asked each to send up samples of their three most outstanding creations.
Eleven chocolatiers responded, which means we sampled 33 different filled candies. And we did it blindas in blindfolded. Pure taste was what we were after.
Tasting comments ranged from, "Tastes like Lemon Pledge" to "Wow, I want more," from "The bomb!" to "An insult to human life." Sadly, all the hazelnut chocolates tasted of stale nuts. And interestingly, the topping-chocolates-with-coarse-salt trend that started five years ago is going strong, with good results. I was surprised at how many salted caramels got us raving.
We came up with a handful of outstanding gift possibilities. These are our picks:
- Fran's in Seattle: "Gray Salt Caramels." These are little bars of caramel dipped in dark chocolate and topped with crystals of salt. Sweet, salt, sticky, smooth - truly stunning.
- Ethel's in Chicago: Two choices: A chocolate filled with a cream of peanut butter and jelly that tastes like afternoons after school, really fine, and a white chocolate filled with pumpkin pie, which tasted to me like hot chili and spice.
- Valerie's Confections in California: There was a salt-and-pepper truffle I am stashing away, and chocolate-covered almond toffee crunch topped with fleur de sel that was like a sophisticated Heath Bar. I quote: "The bomb."
- Brian T. McElrath in Minneapolis: A white and dark chocolate shell filled with tart, fresh-tasting passion fruit cream was another stunner. And his butterfly-shaped, salted caramel-filled chocolate was up there with the best.
Contact Information for Our Selections:
Fran's Chocolates
Seattle, WA
206.322.0233
www.franschocolates.com
Ethel's Chocolate Lounge
Chicago, IL
702.547.0773/702.207.9418
www.ethelschocolate.com
Valerie Confections
Los Angeles, CA
888.706.1408
www.valerieconfections.com/store
BT McElrath
Minneapolis, MN
612.331.8800
www.btmcelrath.com
For your reference, this is the list of all eleven chocolatiers who submitted samples:
Valerie Confections
Los Angeles, CA
888.706.1408
www.valerieconfections.com/store
Intemperantia
Pacific Palisades, CA
800.982.0088
www.intemperantia.com
Recchiuti Confections
San Francisco, CA
415.986.1593
www.recchiuti.com
Ethel's Chocolate Lounge
Chicago, IL
702.547.0773/702.207.9418
www.ethelschocolate.com
Chocolat Celeste
Saint Paul, MN
651.644.3823
www.chocolatceleste.com
Byrne & Carlson
Portsmouth, NH
888.559.9778
www.byrneandcarlson.com
Marie Belle
New York, NY
212.925.6999
www.mariebelle.com
Christopher Norman
New York, NY 212.402.1243
www.christophernormanchocolates.com
Fran's Chocolates
Seattle, WA
206.322.0233
www.franschocolates.com
River Chocolate Co.
River Falls, WI
715.273.3731
www.localharvest.org/member/M6993
BT McElrath
Minneapolis, MN
612.331.8800
www.btmcelrath.com
Some photos of Lynne and crew conducting the highly unscientific and thoroughly non-quantitative taste testing in The Splendid Table studios.
Special thanks to Johnny Vince Evans for providing taking the photos and sharing them with us.



Back to Gourmet's Guide
|